Spielevergleich XBox360/Wii/PS3

[Lordchen]

hab da grad was sehr interessantes bei Neogaf gefunden. Denk mal das wird hier auch einige interessieren

According to various message boards on the Internet every now and then, from time to time it’s quite often that you’ll catch posts/threads ranting about too many shooters being on the Xbox 360, or how the Xbox 360 needs more variety in their selection of titles; both being very legitiment observations and discussions. In no way, shape or form am I saying that it is completely untrue. So, I thought I’d take some time out of my day to form a mini study on what software exactly is on the Xbox 360. Based on 137 Xbox 360 games, I found that not even a fourth of them are considered as First Person Shooters or Third Person Shooters, even added together. The study includes the majority of the Xbox 360 games that have been released or to be released this month(August), as for all other titles; Halo 3 included, were not added as they haven’t been released. Also, XBLA games were not factored in and neither was Virtual Console games for the Wii section of this study.

Now before we go further, let me point out that for a game to be considered an FPS accordingly; it must have the first person perspective view, and contain mainly shooting elements. For a game to be considered a TPS accordingly; it must have the third person perspective view and contain mainly shooting elements as well. Two good examples of these type of genres on Xbox 360 are Call of Duty 3 and Gears of War. Both titles stick with the shooting element throughout the game which is why they are always defined as FPSs/TPSs rather then Action.

Out of the 137 games that I have recorded and based on this study, (each title was placed within a genre that defines them), and as I did this I found that there are only 15 FPS titles and 8 TPS titles.

As of note; if you find a title I didn’t add, please send me a comment and I will add it. All titles were placed in genres that we I felt was probable.

* FPS 11%
* TPS 6%
* Fighting 3%
* Sports 26%
* RPG 6%
* Driving/Racing/Flight 13%
* RTS/Puzzle 3%
* Action/Action Adventure 26%
* Family/Party 6%

Xbox 360

FPS 11%

Battlefield 2 MC
Rainbow Six Vegas
Prey
The Darkness
Quake 4
BioShock
Perfect Dark Zero
Call of Juarez
Call of Duty 2
Call of Duty 3
History Channel: Civil War
Hour of Victory
F.E.A.R.
Far Cry Instincts Predator
Shadowrun

TPS 6%

Gears of War
Crackdown
Earth Defense Force 2017
Lost Planet
Bullet Witch
Stranglehold
GRAW
GRAW 2

Fighting 3%

Rumble Roses Double X
Dead or Alive 4
WWE Smackdown vs RAW 2007
Def Jam ICON

Sports/Extreme 26%

Madden NFL 08
Madden NFL 07
Madden NFL 06
All Pro Football 2k8
2006 FIFA World Cup
Amped 3
NBA 2K7
NBA 2K6
Dead or Alive Xtreme 2
Fight Night Round 3
FIFA 07
FIFA 06
MLB 2K7
MLB 2K6
NHL 07
NCAA Football 08
NCAA Football 07
NBA Street: Homecourt
NBA Live 07
NBA Live 06
NHL 2K7
NHL 2K6
Rockstar Table Tennis
Rapala Fishing Tournament
Tiger Woods PGA 07,
Tiger Woods PGA 08,
Tiger Woods PGA 06,
Tony Hawk's American Wasteland,
Tony Hawk's Project 8,
Virtual Tennis 3,
WE: Pro Evolution 2007,
The Bigs,
Blitz: The League,
College Hoops 2K6,
College Hoops 2K7,
Surfs up,

RPG 6%

Two Worlds,
Oblivion,
Blue Dragon,
Enchanted Arms,
Final Fantasy XI,
Phantasy Star Universe,
Marvel: Ultimate Alliance,
Dynasty Warriors: Gundam

Racing/Driving/Flying: 13%

Burnout Revenge,
Blazing Angles,
DiRT,
Forza 2,
Import Tuner Challenge,
Moto GP 06,
Moto GP 07,
NFS Carbon,
NFS Most Wanted,
Over G Fighters,
PGR3,
Project Slypheed,
Ridge Racer 6,
NASCAR 08,
Pimp My Ride,
Test Drive: Unlimited,
Cars

RTS/Puzzle: 3%

Command and Conquer 3
Battlestations Midway
Tetris Evolution
Star Trek Legacy

Action/Action Adventure: 26%

Condemned Criminal Origins,
Dead Rising,
Fantastic 4,
Gun,
Hitman Blood Money,
Just Cause,
Lego Star Wars: The Original Trilogy,
King Kong,
Saints Row,
Spiderman 3,
Tenchu Z,
Vampire Rain,
Eragon,
Kameo,
Full Auto,
Overlord,
Pirates of the Caribbean; At World’s End,
Sonic The Hedgehog,
Tomb Raider Legend,
The outfit,
Transformers: The Game,
Splinter Cell: DA, ,
Bionicle Heroes,
Superman Returns,
The Godfather,
TMNT,
X-Men The Game,
Dynasty Warriors 5,
Monster Madness,
Ninety Nine Nights,
Amored Core 4,
Bomberman Act Zero,
Chromehounds, ,
Disney’s Meet the Robinsons,
Ratatouille.
Shrek the third

Party/Family: 6%

DDR Universe,
Fusion Frenzy 2,
Guitar Hero II,
Harry Potter OOTP,
Open Season
Viva Piñata,
WSOP TOC,
WSP All In,
Rayman RR,



PS3

Total PS3 games: 53Fighting: 4%Def Jam Icon,
Virtual Fighter 5,

Sports: 34%All Pro Football 2K8,
College Hoops 2K7,
Fight Night Round 3,
Madden NFL 08,
MLB 07: The Show,
MLB 2K7,
Madden NFL 07,
NCAA Football 2008,
NBA 2K7,
NBA Street: Homecourt,
NBA 07,
NHL 2K7,
Tiger Woods PGA Tour 08,
Tiger woods pga tour 07
Tony Hawk’s Project 8,
The Bigs,
Virtual Tennis 3,

First Person Shooters: 9%FEAR, Resistance Fall of Man, Rainbow Six: Vegas, The Darkness, Call of Duty 3

Third Person Shooters: 4%GRAW 2, Warhawk

RPG: 7%Enchanted Arms,
Oblivion,
Dynasty Warriors: Gundam,
Marvel: Ultimate Alliance,

Racing/Driving/Flying: 16%Blazing Angels,
Formula 1: Championship edition,
Motor storm,
NFS Carbon,
Ridge Racer 7,
Fatal Inertia,
NASCAR 08,
Sega Rally Revo,
Stuntman: Ignition

Action/Adventure: 24%Genji: Days of Blade,
Ninja Gaiden: Sigma,
Pirates of Caribbean, ,
Splinter Cell Double Agent,
Sonic The Hedgehog,
Transformers: The Game,
Full Auto 2,
Fantastic 4: ROTSS,
Gauntlet 2,
Spiderman 3,
Armored Core 4,
Godfather: The Don’s Edition,
Mobile Suit Gundam: Crossfire,

RTS/Puzzle: 0%

Wonder if we missed something.....

Family/Party: 2%
Harry Potter OOTP

Wii

Total Wii Games: 77

Fighting: 8%Dragon Ball Z: Budokai T 2,
Legend of the Dragon,
Mortal Kombat: Armageddon,
Pokemon Battle Revolution,
Guity Gear XX Accent Core,
The Grim Adventures of Billy & Mandy,

Sports: 15.5%Brunswick Pro Bowling,
Mario Strikers Charged,
Madden NFL 08,
Madden NFL 07,
Rapala Tournament Fishing,
SSX Blur,
The Bigs,
Tiger Woods PGA Tour 07,
Tiger Woods PGA Tour 08,
Wii Sports,
Tony Hawk’s Downhill Jam,
Surfs Up,

First Person Shooters: 6.5%Metroid Prime 3 Corruption(some what, then again, action/adventure?), Far Cry: Vengeance, Red Steel, Call of Duty 3, Medal of Honor: Vanguard,


RPG: 5%Alien Syndrome,
Paper Mario,
Marvel Ultimate Alliance,
Super Paper Mario

Racing/Driving/flying: 10.5%Blazing Angels,
CARS,
Driver Parallel Lines,
Excite Truck,
GT Pro Series,
HeatSeeker,
NFS Carbon,
Monster 4x4 world Circuit,

Action/Adventure: 35%Avatar: The Last Airbender,
Meet the Robinsons,
Elebits,
Fantastic 4: ROTSS,
Harry Potter and the OOTP,
Happy Feet,
Ice Age 2: The Meltdown,
Open Season,
Prince of Persia: Rival Swords,
Pirates of the Caribbean: At World‘s End,
Resident Evil 4 Wii Edition,
Ratatouille,
Sonic and the Secret Rings,
Spiderman 3,
The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess,
Transformers: The Game,
Splinter Cell Double Agent,
The Godfather: Blackhand Edition,
WarioWare: Smooth Moves,
TMNT,
SpongeBob SquarePants: Creature from Kustry Krab, shrek the third,
Scarface,
Escape from Bug Island,
Disney’s Chicken Little: Ace in Action,
Bionicle Heroes ,
the ant bully

Party/Family: 13%WSOP; ToC,
Wii Play,
Mario Party 8,
Rayman Raving Rabbids,
Mercury Meltdown Revolution,
Barnyard,
Cooking Mama: Cook Off,
Chicken Shoot,
Carnival Games,
Boogie,

Puzzle: 6.5%Kororinpa: Marble Mania,
Bust-A-Move: Bash,
Big Brain Academy: Wii Degree,
Super Monkey Ball: Banana Blitz
Adventures of Lolo

http://fpssource.net/2007/08/08/17-of-all-xbox-360-titles-are-fpstps/

 

[Bill G4tes]

Hab ich es jetzt überlesen, oder fehlt "Schlacht um Mittelerde" in der Liste?

Ausserdem fehlen die Arcade-Titel...

 

[evilsonic]

Also, XBLA games were not factored in and neither was Virtual Console games for the Wii section of this study.

 

[Lordchen]

Vor allem die Sportspieldominanz bei den HD-Konsolen ist schon krass.
PS3 34%, 360 26%

Und das Mysterium dass auf Wii nur Minispiele erscheinen kann man mit der Liste wohl auch gut widerlegen, nur 13 - 20% ca. wenn mans sie richtig rechnet

 

[Sigistauffen]

Die Shooter Dominanz auf der 360 ist trotzdem enorm. Nicht unbedingt, weil es jetzt unbedingt zu wenige Vertreter von anderen genres gibt, sondern weil fast jedes AAA game einfach ein shooter ist (ob jetzt first oder third person). Was waren die Top Xbox games in diesem Jahr? Lost Planet, R6 Vegas und The Darkness. Im Herbst kommen noch Bioshock, Stranglehold, Halo3, Call of Duty4 etc. dazu, also auch alles shooter.
Klar gibt es ein paar RPGs, aber ausser Oblivion keines, was man wirklich haben muss. (desweiteren sind Blue Dragon oder Gundam weder im Handel erhältlich, noch machen sie jetzt einen unglaublich tollen Eindruck) Action Adventures gibts ganze 2 Stück: TR ist dabei lediglich ein update der last gen Versionen und Kameo ist im Vergleich zu den AAA adventures der letzten Generation auch nur gehobener Durchschnitt. Angekündigt ist auf dem genre auch nix neues.

Was die Sportspiele angeht: solange EA nicht irgendwann konkurs geht wird es die weiterhin in rauhen Mengen geben, aber das war in der letzten Generation auch nicht anders.

 

[DoktorTetris]

Sagen wir mal so, auf Ego Shooter wird bei der 360 einen besonderen Wert gelegt und die Fans störts ja anscheinend auch nicht.
Aber ob PC oder 360, es kommt ja schon fast alle 2 Monate ein neuer Ego Shooter raus, vielleicht liegt das auch daran, dass die Prgrammierer langsam wissen, wie der Hase läuft in diesem Genre.
Hinzu kommt noch, dass man sich die Animation der Hauptperson sparen kann, bei einem Uncharted beispielsweise spielt man ja in der dritten Person, sprich, man sieht, wie er über Steine hopst, aus höherer Entfernung irgendwo runterspringt oder über nen umgefallenen Baumstamm balanciert.

Mich interessiert eigentlich nicht, wieviel Sportspiele oder sonstige Sachen noch für die 360 rauskommen, die Box sollte ab und an auch mal ein paar genre-unübliche Spiele bekommen und wenn es einfach mal nur ein lustiges Arcade Game ist.